ICT Direction

A number of areas within the school have been identified as needing immediate attention. These are:

  • Com 4 is unusable due to hardware failure. Reinstating this room is a priority
  • Issuing all staff with laptops to aid in the development of computer based lessons
  • Choosing appropriate netbooks/laptops for the students
  • Rationalisation of software within the school

With new computers for Com 4 needed immediately and the imminent arrival of laptops/netbooks for the students, it's important to make sure we purchase the correct hardware and software to suit the needs of our staff and students. Ideally this means installing and maintaining one type of system. At present the CEO is looking to implement PC based hardware utilising open source software. While this is a viable option the question is, is this the best option available?

To better understand the direction computer hardware should take within the school for both students and staff, we are asking for your thoughts and comments on what type of system should be deployed.

Below are the three main options available to us and some of the the pro's and con's for each. Over the next two (2) weeks your comments and input are invited.



Microsoft based windows PC

xpPro.jpg PRO's
  • For most staff / students these machines are familiar
  • Supported and maintained by the CEO
  • Hardware is relativley inexpensive

CON's
  • Microsoft Windows is expensive to purchase and maintain
  • Comes with very little extra software installed
  • Need to install a lot of extra plug-ins to make it compatible with most applications
  • Viruses and malware more prevelant with Windows based PC's
  • Laptops can be slow to start up from sleep mode


Open Source PC

linux-penguin.jpg PRO's
  • Similar hardware to a Windows based PC
  • Software is either inexpensive or free
  • Hardware is relatively inexpensive
  • Supported and maintained by the CEO

CON's
  • Software often has 'bugs' that cause malfunctions
  • Often little or no software support from manufacturer

Mac

leopard.jpg PRO's
  • Reliable hardware and software
  • Few viruses and malware
  • Comes with other applications pre-installed
  • Battery life on laptops very good
  • Fast start up from sleep mode
  • Apple provide support for education institutions

CON's
  • More expensive
  • Many staff members may be unfamiliar with Mac's and how they work
  • Not supported and maintained by the CEO (The CEO has now acknowledged that the PC option may not be the only one and will provide support where necessary)


To leave a comment on this topic click on the Discussion tab at the top of the page.
In the Subject box type ICT Direction.
Enter your message/comment/pro/con etc and click the Post button.